Planning

How to compare creative service quotes fairly

Compare scope, ownership, feedback, costs and aftercare so the decision is based on the work you actually need.

By Graphic Core   /   Published
Monthly guide series: October 2019

A brass balance scale holding two stacks of folders beside a calculator and pencil.

Start with the same brief

A lower headline figure can represent excellent value, a smaller scope or missing information. Before comparing prices, give suppliers the same short description of the problem, audience, deliverables, deadline and constraints. Ask them to identify any assumptions and suggest alternatives separately. If one proposal includes strategy and another only production, record the difference rather than treating them as identical. You do not need to award a project simply because you requested a quote, but respond respectfully and handle any information shared in confidence appropriately.

Compare deliverables and boundaries

List what each supplier will provide, in what format and for which intended uses. For branding, this might include concepts, agreed logo variations and a basic usage guide; for a website, it might include content planning, design, development, testing and handover. Check what is specifically excluded. A supplier may quote for design while another includes implementation, or one may require you to provide finished copy. Mark any ambiguity as a question. Make sure the work addresses the customer task you described, not just a list of attractive files.

Understand the review process

Ask how the project moves from brief to first presentation, feedback, revision and approval. A proposal should make clear how many review stages are included, what counts as an out-of-scope change and who provides the final decision. More revisions do not always create a better outcome if the brief or decision process is unclear. Check whether delays in providing content or feedback affect the schedule, and ask how significant changes are priced before they are made. Agree who consolidates comments from your team.

Ask each supplier to show how feedback moves through the project. For example, an initial direction might be reviewed once, followed by an agreed round of amendments to the selected direction. Another quote may include fewer concepts but more time for testing. Neither structure is automatically better; compare it with the decisions your team needs to make. Establish who signs off each stage and how additional requests are estimated. If the proposal uses unfamiliar terms such as ‘concept’ or ‘revision’, ask for a short example so both sides mean the same thing. Revisit the comparison if a supplier identifies an important item that was not originally specified.

Check costs over the useful life

Look beyond the initial project price. Depending on the work, there may be printing, hosting, domain renewal, software, image licences, accessibility review or ongoing maintenance to consider. Ask which charges recur, who pays them directly and whether the figures include applicable tax. A supplier cannot always know every future cost, but they can identify the known assumptions and responsibilities. Record the one-off and recurring items separately. Do not assume that a low initial fee includes every update, licence or support request indefinitely.

Build a comparison using the same headings for every quote: initial work, printing or implementation, third-party licences, recurring services and optional support. Enter an item as ‘not confirmed’ when the proposal does not provide enough information. For a purely illustrative calculation, an initial fee of £600 plus a separately stated £10 monthly service would mean £720 over the first twelve months if the service ran for the full year; taxes, setup fees and any other costs would depend on the actual agreement. This is arithmetic for comparison, not a quoted price or market rate.

Ask about rights and handover

Creative work may include original artwork and licensed third-party materials. Ask whether the proposal transfers copyright or grants a licence, what uses are permitted, whether the licence continues if the relationship ends, and who owns or controls the relevant accounts. Request a list of included file formats and agree whether source or editable files are included. For a website, discuss access, backups, documentation and responsibility for updates. Keep the final agreement and licence information in a place the business can find later.

Consider communication and fit

A well-matched supplier should be able to explain its proposed approach and the questions it needs answered. Consider relevant experience, accessibility of communication, realistic availability and whether responsibilities are clear. Ask for examples the supplier is entitled to share and check what part of each example they actually delivered. Do not assume a larger portfolio proves that a specific team member will work on your project. Equally, a smaller supplier may be a good fit when the work and support arrangements match your needs.

Illustrative example: the work behind a figure

Imagine an invented project plan that allocates two hours to a brief, six to design, two to feedback and one to handover. The accompanying chart is an illustration of how work can be broken down, not a market rate, a forecast or a claim about a real project. A supplier might use different stages and estimates. Use the breakdown to ask what is included and which assumptions affect the total; do not treat the proportions as a benchmark for the time any particular project should require.

ILLUSTRATIVE CHART

Example: a possible creative project breakdown

  • Brief2 hours
  • Design6 hours
  • Feedback2 hours
  • Handover1 hour
Illustrative example, not measured results. These figures are not a quote or a typical project estimate.

Separate an omission from an exclusion

An exclusion is something the supplier has said is outside the quote; an omission may simply be an item that neither side has discussed. Mark both in your comparison and ask for clarification. For example, a website proposal that does not mention copywriting may rely on supplied text, while another may include an interview and draft. Ask what happens if materials arrive late or additional work is requested. This creates a clearer basis for a decision without assuming that any one supplier has made a mistake.

Make the decision and record it

Use a simple comparison sheet with scope, exclusions, fees, third-party costs, timing, approvals, rights and support. Ask each supplier to clarify differences that matter, and ensure any changes are reflected in an updated proposal. Decide which option best meets the business need and budget rather than selecting on one number alone. Before work begins, agree the payment schedule, deliverables, responsibilities and the process for handling changes in writing. Keep the agreed brief and proposal together for the people who will manage the project.

YOUR NEXT MOVE / 01

Ready to make
more of your business?

Tell us about your website, your services and where you want to grow.

START A CONVERSATION